Scientists at the Global Nonsense Observation Centre (GNOC) have reported dangerously high concentrations of nonsense in mainstream media reporting of climate change.

Satellite observations have picked up a spike in nonsense levels in climate reporting over the past few days, occurring on top of an already high background level. It is believed to be related to the annual climate phenomenon known as ‘COP’.

Chief Scientist of GNOC Katherine Hey-Ho explains: “This is when media attention that is normally distributed across topics such as wars, politics and celebrity sex scandals suddenly flows into the field of climate change and concentrates there for a few days, before returning to where it came from. In some media outlets it can result in as much climate nonsense being broadcast in 48 hours as is usually experienced in the rest of the year, with devastating results.”

The source of the nonsense is understood to be a failure to recognise that nothing of substance is being negotiated in the negotiations. Faced with the challenge of explaining what is happening, journalists then fall back on meaningless climate jargon.

Renowned expert in climate tipping points Professor Timothy Lentils has recently published research on early-warning signals. He says words like ‘ambition’, ‘cycle’, ‘ratchet’, and ‘mechanism’ are strong indicators of the presence of nonsense, particularly when two or more of them are used together.

Other scientists believe there is a connection to the ‘blocking’ observed in the stream of logical thought that normally flows rapidly in a relatively straight line, but that in the field of climate change has been observed to slow down, meander, and sometimes stop altogether. The ‘transition away from fossil fuels’ is described as if it was somehow different from the transition towards clean technologies – as if one could happen while the other did not. The objective of stopping burning fossils is confused with the means of doing so, as if restricting the supply of fossils were the only method – disregarding the success being achieved all over the world in destroying demand for fossils. The haggling over words to describe collective global goals is confused with the presence or absence of actions to achieve them.

Physicist Tim Palmtree says that in the information ecosystem, all these things are connected. “When logical reasoning fails in one part of the system, the whole system is affected.”

One of the most concerning developments over the past decade is a rise in the level of spurious attribution, which is ten times more potent than most other forms of nonsense. Statements such as ‘before the Paris Agreement, the world was on track for four degrees of warming; now thanks to that agreement we are on track for more like 2.5 degrees of warming’ are being observed with increasing regularity.

Pioneer of climate attribution studies Professor Peter Spott says “There is no scientific basis for these statements. The contribution of solar and wind to global useful energy production has been growing exponentially since the 1980s; there is no detectable change in the trend either side of the year 2015. The fact that governments underestimated the rate of technological progress in earlier years is evidence of shortcomings in governments’ analytical capabilities, not of the effectiveness of any diplomatic process. And where governments have made successful policies, there is no reason to assume that these are attributable to climate diplomacy in general or to the UNFCCC negotiations in particular.”

The London-based climate campaigner Greasie Fatberg believes more attention should be given to the influence of vested interests. “The negotiations process provides jobs and prestige to the people in it”, she says. “Of course some of them want to give it an air of mystery and importance. That’s understandable. What beggars belief is that journalists simply accept what they say, instead of questioning it critically.”

Veteran climate scientist Professor James Hamstrung believes he has an explanation. For the past thirty years, he and his team at the Global Underground Research Network (GURN) have been using the Large Braincell Collider to try to detect signs of the professional scepticism in climate reporting that theory predicts should exist. “We’re still looking”, he says, “but it’s hard to find. Even normal curiosity about questions like how diplomacy succeeds in other fields, or what useful, practical climate diplomacy could look like, is only rarely observed. Finding the Higgs boson was less difficult than this.”

Disclaimer: This is a fictional media report. Any similarity to real people or events is entirely coincidental.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *